Weekly Poetry/Poetics Commentary by Bob GrummanWeek Thirteen--27 April 1999
Observations for Silent But Deadly #9
Now that C. Mulrooney has exposed my "seemingly inexhaustible
capacity to be . . . blind and deaf to anything worthwhile," it's
probably not proper for me to have at the poems up for grabs this
time around, but--being addicted to pontificating, I will, anyway.
So, to begin, let me say that I liked Mary Winters's poem (sorry,
Mary), especially its reference to her manure and butane torch cure
for plantar warts; except that it's funny and competent, I can't think
of anything else to say about it.
You Don't Want a Stranger
Why are there so many
rutted crossroads
A home remedy's the best.
And what do they know?
Write me and I'll tell you how
and a butane torch.
Ever see those ads in the subway
a nail file.
Eel Leonard is as good at the jump-cut as anyone in the Ashbery
school, but much funnier; and funnier than poets like Denson and
Mulrooney because his images are more crazy-right--for inst, his
"pill of wet sense." The scrawled-in "rien," underlined to make sure
we realize how Important it is, is typical of the kind of proofs of
insanity with which Mr. L., by whatever name, laces his zaneries.
He is a master. Here's his poem:
Avon Calling in
Uranus
Many are grayer
than my stomach
counts halfway
between loving rien
going raisins
Gabe Neruda's poem, "Our fabled lady eludes the dragons," bothered me for a couple of reads--it seemed
too arch, and too vague. The first few lines are a trace too corny,
and get the tone off, for me. I'd prefer "muses" to "ponders," and
I'm not sure what "for a moment" is doing in the second line. That
breathing sounds may come to seem prisons and poisons
makes more sense to me than the way Neruda has it, but I admit to
not having the firmest of grips on what he's trying to say, though I
read the poem to be about Cassandra's regret over previous
licentiousness, which the water heals. I've come to quite like the
piece.
Our fabled lady
eludes the dragons.
"Every breathing
sound may seem a prison
One spirit replies
among her selves, "And yet
Cassandra says in
murmur
"O the water
emits
Pat McKinnon's poem, "My Brother and the Bees," seems competent, heartfelt, genuine, but the
dream isn't deconventionalizing enough to give the poem the heft an
earlier one of McKinnon's in Silent But Deadly had. He's a tick
better than Heather Lowe with bees, but not enough better. His
eye for pertinent, effectively-coloring details is excellent, but--well,
I guess the poem comes too close to Norman Rockwell (though,
yeah, a disenchanted Norm) for me to more than mildly appreciate
it.
My Brother and
the Bees
When we were
kids my brother caught bees
He liked to carry
them back to our room
Years later out by
the pool
He now rents a
house in Alum Rock
I call him on the
phone
He says They
come like a writhing black funnel
Richard King Perkins II's poem about Lawrence is super-swift and
competent, with an exactly-right punch-line. Nice combination of
surrealistic situation and quotidian props (like shoes, pants, a bus
station). Another likable poem that's hard to criticize, but which
doesn't do anything whammo. Not that every poem should, but . . .
Stolen Moments
in Araby
Lawrence jumps
out of the poem
That does it for the poems on review, but I can't quit now, for
there's still Lou Hertz to contend with. Hertz is much more amiable
and sound of mind than Mulrooney, but if he's going to tell us
something is not poetry (in this case, Alan Catlin's exercise in
computer degeneracy), he must tell us why it isn't--objectively. Nor
should he advocate its not being published in poetry journals, unless
he's positive that he can't be wrong in determining whether a given
text is poetry or not. Even then, why not publish it, anyway, to
publicize what isn't poetry and why? More important, of course,
would be what isn't GOOD poetry and why, and vice versa--
questions, I'm sad to note, that fewer and fewer of the contributors
to SBD seem to be interested in.
|