December 19, 1997

The Nation



Choppers grounded by sanctions


The economic sanctions against Burma are hurting US business such as the maker of the Bell helicopters which are used by the junta to fight druglords, reports Richard Ehrlich.

Bangkok, Thailand

Burmese generals have Texas made Bell helicopters for use against opponents and druglords, but Bell and others in the helicopter industry are losing US$5 million a year because of US sanctions against the unelected military regime.

A US helicopter manufacturing representative, who asked not to be identified, said Bell officials are "not too comfortable about associating Bell with Burma".

"It's got very political in the US," he added.

It is unfair, the representative said because "people have indicated that the helicopter and fixed-wing planes [Bell] had up there, were doing a job".

The US-led sanctions against Burma have been in response to alleged widespread extrajudicial killings, torture, imprisonment and other abuses of human rights.

The US and others have also called for Burma's Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung San Suu Kyi, to be allowed to head an elected government.

London-based Amnesty International, the US State Department, and other groups insist the Burmese military has, in the past decade, killed thousands of pro-democracy demonstrators, ethnic minorities and others, while continuing to torture opponents.

Burma consistently denies all such charges.

The helicopter representative, however, praised Bell's role in helping to torch Burma's vast fields of illicit opium, which produce most of the world's heroin.

In the past, thanks to Bell, Washington was "able to monitor it, the US government was in there, monitoring it".

But the sanctions knocked out the US anti-opium efforts in Burma, he said. "It's a shame."

Today, Bell has "around 25 helicopters in Burma, sitting there basically".

But Bell officials back in Texas "are not complaining".

They predict the Burmese will eventually spruce up all the Bell choppers and use them.

"One of these days, they are going to do something. But it will cost them more, the longer you let this stuff sit"

The helicopter representative was speaking at the Defense Asia '97 exhibition in Bangkok, where Bradley tanks, Greek missile systems, F-16 warplanes, bombs from India, and other international weaponry were on display for regional customers.

In addition to Bell Helicopter, which is a subsidiary of Fort Worth-based Textron Inc. US participants included the Association of the United States Army, Booz-Allen and Hamilton, Caterpillar, ITT, Litton Laser Systems, Northrop Grumman, Smith and Wesson, Boeing, Pratt and Whitney and others.

Bell and Burma, however, remained distant.

When Burma's self-styled State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) seized power by trashing an election which gave Suu Kyi's party a landslide victory, Bell's business with the junta came to a halt.

Bell had been "delivering stuff there in the 1970s to mid-1980s. They're older Hueys. Type 205-Als. Civilian Hueys," the representative said.

"After the 1988 military takeover, basically it's not been clear. There has been an indication: 'You wouldn't be well-received to be selling there'."

That indication was not expressed by Burma's miffed military - but "by the US".

Up to then, American taxpayers funded the Bells-to-Burma deals.

"The US government was paying for the spare parts and the procurement of [Bell] aircraft, purchasing the aircraft. They terminated the programme."

The Bells were billed as part of Washington's International Narcotics Matters, usually known by its acronym INM, "to suppress the drug business", he said.

Washington "withdrew that support."

Today, the helicopters remain in Burma.

"I don't think they're flying now. They're all in hangars. It's tit for tat. They say, 'You guys stopped the programme', so they pretty much stayed away from us, and will continue the way it is, until there has to be a political solution acceptable to the Western countries before it will be business as usual."

ERADICATING INSURGENTS


The helicopters were not used only in drug eradication, however.

Bells were also helping to kill insurgents and others opposed to the regime, according to minority ethnic Karen rebels.

The rebels have remnants from helicopters they say were shot down in 1983 and 1984.

A senior Karen guerrilla leader said: "The Burmese government was using US-supplied helicopters to bring in big 105-mm guns and ammunition to the front."

To prove his point, the guerrilla leader displayed large fragments of two helicopters he said were shot down in June 1983, at Mah Po Kay, near the border with Thailand.

"These are the remains of the gift from the American people to the Burmese government," the guerrilla said, holding a fragment of a helicopters which bore part of a label reading "serial number A3-07271 FBW196, part number 212-010..."

The US helicopter representative said, however, that because of the sanctions, Burmese generals "in the 1990s ... went out and bought a whole load of Polish helicopters. I heard in excess of 30.

"It's an opportunity lost" not only for Bell, but for the entire US helicopter industry, he said.

Bell and others lost the cash flowing from US taxpayers which would have continued to pay for spare parts and servicing.

Fresh antidrug arguments, meanwhile, are being used to try and overcome that hurdle.

"The war on drugs should be exactly that, a war. You don't let politics or anything interfere," the helicopter man said.

"Here's an opportunity to get rid of that stuff. If the Burmese were willing to monitor and participate in that [anti-opium] programme, it sounds like a winner for everyone."

If there had not been an embargo all these years, Bell could have sold Burma "six or eight helicopters, in the $5-million range, each. Utility helicopters. 'Ash and Trash', we call them. You're hauling soldiers to suppress things, moving people around to do these jobs. Like a taxi. Like a utility truck.

"When you are suppressing the [opium] crops, they are used to burn the crops."

The spare parts money currently being lost by Bell because of the embargo would have totaled "a couple of million dollars a year. Two hundred thousand dollars a month".

"I hope eventually there's a lot more emphasis on what do we [Americans] lose economically. You lose the spare parts business. You lose the opportunity to find new opportunities. Opportunities for human purposes, for antinarcotics ability.

"On a yearly basis, $5 million" is lost by Americans in the helicopter industry who can't deal in Burma.

But even if the human rights sanctions were lifted today, the Burmese are now married to the Polish choppers.

"To woo them back will take years. They're full. The guys who made that decision, the Burmese military, have to keep supporting them [the Polish helicopters] for years, as long as they are around, because otherwise it looks like they made a mistake."

The Warsaw aircraft should survive "20 to 30 years".

In April, Washington unveiled a ban on new investment in Burma.

Secretary of State Madeleine Albright warned the pariah regime that it was moving in the "dangerous and disappointing direction" of wide-spread repression.





Copyright by Richard S. Ehrlich
email: animists *at* yahoo dot com

Website, more Asia news plus the non-fiction book of interviews, documentation and investigative journalism, titled: "Hello My Big Big Honey!" Love Letters to Bangkok Bar Girls and Their Revealing Interviews

at: http://www.oocities.org/asia_correspondent