The other day while doing my usual 47-minute
workout in the gym, "Madonna Rewind" happened to be on VH1 on
one of the flat screen televisions hanging from the ceiling.
I'm no fan of VH1 or Madonna. But on the
screen where I was watching ESPN Sports Center, a commercial was
running, and my attention was momentarily diverted to her new
war video on the adjacent monitor. She claims she delayed its
release because of the US's involvement in Iraq.
I was curious to see what she had to say so I
pressed the "Up" button on the station selector. I listened just
long enough to hear her whine about how ironic it was that we
fought a war to bring democracy to Iraq, yet there isn't real
democracy here in America because show people are being punished
for their criticism of this country's involvement in the war.
I assume the show people to whom she was
referring were the likes of the Dixie Chicks, Susan Sarandon,
and Tim Robbins, whose recent anti-Bush, anti-America tirades
had some very unpleasant consequences.
Dixie Chicks band member Natalie Maines said
at a performance in London: "Just so you know, we're ashamed the
president of the United States is from Texas." Now the group is
suffering from reduced record sales and outraged deejays
refusing to play their music.
Similarly, when the Baseball Hall of Fame got
wind of Robbins' venomous anti-war rhetoric, they cancelled his
appearance at Cooperstown, where he was scheduled to appear with
Sarandon for a 15-year anniversary celebration of the movie Bull
Durham.
Robbins complained of censorship, telling
attendees at a National Press Club luncheon, "A chill wind is
blowing in this nation. Every day the airwaves are filled with
warnings, veiled and unveiled threats, spewed invective and
hatred directed at any voice of dissent."
Dale Petroskey, president of the Hall wrote,
"We believe your very public criticism of President Bush at this
important and sensitive time in our nation's history helps
undermine the U.S. position which ultimately could put our
troops in even more danger."
Time for a history lesson, folks.
The First Amendment states: "Congress shall
make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or
prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom
of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably
to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of
grievances."
Last time I checked, there weren't any new
laws passed by Congress limiting anyone's free speech. There
were no knocks at Tim Robbins's or Madonna's door in the middle
of the night to take them away for speaking out against the
government.
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the real
world, where not everyone agrees with your point of view,
especially when you choose to disparage the land that has
afforded you the opportunities for which gratitude, not
vilification, should be on your tongue.
There's been no "chill wind" of censorship.
To listen to Robbins' diatribe, you'd think we were in Nazi
Germany c.1938, or Saddam Hussein's Iraq, or Cuba, where Fidel
Castro has recently jailed dozens of journalists.
The way it works in the good old, democratic,
capitalistic United States of America is like this: People have
a right to speak, and other people have a right to listen - or
to not listen. Sometimes they hear something so outrageous that
if it is in their power to prevent others from having to listen,
they take those matters into their own hands.
And sometimes, if they really get mad, they
vote with their pocketbooks and wallets. The Dixie Chicks know
this feeling all too well right now.
That's not a "chill wind." It's called the
free market.
Jesus said, "By your words you will be
justified, and by your words you will be condemned."
Or, in other words, when big shot performers
think their fame automatically gives them a stage on which to
speak their minds on any topic, they need to be reminded that
words - real words, not like the ones they read from a Hollywood
script - have real consequences.