Pirates' Cave

Survivor All-Stars is set once again in the realm of pirates--the Pearl Islands of Panama. The following episode summaries chronicle the exploits of those who dared to play the game again.

EPISODE 1: NOT THE SAME GAME TWICE
AIRDATE: February 1/04
No food, no clean drinking water, no fire...what's a castaway to do? 4 past winners and 14 other memorable players dare to take on the toughest Survivor adventure yet.
Immunity: Chapera/Mogo Mogo
Voted Off: Tina (Saboga)

EPISODE 2: TRIBAL GENEROSITY
AIRDATE: February 5/04
Ethan rallies the Saboga tribe to victory in the first reward challenge, and the tribe's generosity helps all three tribes get fire. Jenna schemes to vote Ethan off while Rudy is walking wounded.
Reward: Saboga
Immunity: Chapera/Mogo Mogo
Voted Off: Rudy (Saboga)

EPISODE 3: HEARTBREAKER
AIRDATE: February 12/04
Things heat up in the Saboga camp when Jerri and Rupert square off over building a shelter. At Mogo Mogo, Richard comes face to face with a shark attack, and an unexpected announcement from a tribe member turns into heartbreak for the survivors.
Reward: Chapera
Special Note: Immunity Challenge and Tribal Council cancelled due to the withdrawal of Jenna M. (Mogo Mogo) from competition

EPISODE 4: STORMY WEATHER
AIRDATE: February 19/04
A massive rainstorm hits the island, destroying Saboga's shelter and sending Jerri into an emotional breakdown. Amber and Boston Rob heat things up at Chapera, and an immunity challenge gets physical between the teams.
Reward: Chapera
Immunity: Saboga/Mogo Mogo
Voted Off: Rob Cesternino (Chapera)

EPISODE 5: ...AND ONE WILL GET IMMUNITY
AIRDATE: February 26/04
A devastating loss in the reward challenge results in the dissolution of Saboga, yet turns into elation for three of the tribe's members as they reunite with familiar faces on their new teams. At Mogo Mogo, Colby, plotting to get rid of Ethan, changes strategies and hatches a new scheme to eliminate Richard.
Reward: Mogo Mogo/Chapera
Immunity: Chapera
Voted Off: Richard (Mogo Mogo)

EPISODE 6: WAR OF WORDS
AIRDATE: March 4/04
Tensions flare at Mogo Mogo when Shii Ann and Colby collide. Lex rises to the challenge of provider, while Sue explodes as a previous incident with Richard pushes her over the edge.
Reward: Mogo Mogo
Note: Immunity challenge cancelled. Sue (Chapera) withdraws from competition

EPISODE 7-1: ALL PART OF THE GAME
AIRDATE: March 11/04
Chapera wins a party on a yacht, choosing to take Kathy along in the hopes of getting information from her. Ethan feels that it was his fault that his tribe came up short, while Lex takes strategy matters into his own hands
Reward/Immunity: Chapera
Voted Off: Colby (Mogo Mogo)

EPISODE 7-2: NICE GUYS DON'T FINISH FIRST THIS TIME
AIRDATE: March 17/04
Rob and Rupert square off at Chapera to be the "dominant male" of the tribe. As the last previous winner left in the game, Ethan's feeling the pressure of being targeted. When Lex tells him openly that he's the next one to go, Ethan's last-ditch efforts to stay alive comes up short.
Reward: Chapera
Immunity: Chapera
Voted Off: Ethan (Mogo Mogo)

RECAP EPISODE: A CLOSER LOOK
AIRDATE: March 24/04
Recapping the first 21 days. Never-before-seen footage includes a Chapera send-up of Saboga going to tribal council

EPISODE 8: TURNABOUT IS FAIR PLAY
AIRDATE: April 1/04
With a merge on the castaways' minds, another twist is thrown their way when the teams are switched up. Rob feels the pain of losing Amber, resulting in a "deal with the devil" scheme to convince Lex to keep her.
Immunity: Mogo Mogo
Voted Off: Jerri (Chapera)

EPISODE 9: FULL CIRCLE
AIRDATE: April 8/04
Jenna and Rupert's adventure comes full circle when the tribes merge to become Chaboga Mogo and go to live on Saboga beach. Two immunities are up for grabs in a high-stakes challenge, and Rob does a dirty deed when he double-crosses Lex.
Reward: Rupert
Immunity: Kathy/Rob
Voted Off: Lex

EPISODE 10-1: I SECOND THAT EMOTION
AIRDATE: April 15/04
Bad blood cools down when the castaways are shown clips of videos from home. Rob pulls a "wolf in sheep's clothing" act when he gives up his own reward to let the others in on the deal. Is it a change of heart, or a strategic move?
Reward/Immunity: Rob
Voted Off: Kathy

EPISODE 10-2: NO HOLDS BARRED
AIRDATE: April 22/04
With Kathy gone, Shii Ann is the last original Mogo Mogo standing and feels that she is the next target, so she is determined to win immunity. When that happens, the power players of the old Chapera tribe aren't as powerful as they think they are.
Reward: Rupert
Immunity: Shii Ann
Voted Off: Alicia

EPISODE 11: THE GLOVES COME OFF
AIRDATE: April 29/04
With 9 days left in the game, tension is building between the six players left. Jenna and Shii Ann want each other gone while the bond between Jenna and Rupert is coming undone, with Rupert wishing he had never made an alliance with her in the first place.
Reward: Tom
Immunity: Tom
Voted Off: Shii Ann

EPISODE 12: TRUST NOBODY
AIRDATE: May 6/04
Total paranoia ensues in the camp as the remaining players eye the finish line. Rob gets Rupert and Tom fighting in an elaborate plan to get them riled up, and he and Amber continue their scheming ways. Will anyone take Shii Ann's last words seriously as the showdown goes into the final three days?
Reward: Rob
Immunity: Rob
Voted Off: Tom

EPISODE 13: END OF THE LINE
AIRDATE: May 9/04
Amber, Jenna, Rob or Rupert...who will be the ultimate All-Star? The final four's fate is left to destiny as yet another Survivor adventure comes to an end. Only Jeff and the jury know for sure.
Immunity-Day 37: Amber
Voted Off-Day 37: Rupert
Immunity-Day 38: Rob M.
Voted Off-Day 38: Jenna L.
Runner-Up: Rob M.
Final Survivor: Amber

SURVIVOR ALL-STARS: THE REUNION
The 18 All-Stars reunite in New York in this live special to talk about their experiences in Panama with Jeff. Included is a surprise so secret, it's guaranteed to blow the players away.

AMERICA'S TRIBAL COUNCIL
AIRDATE: May 16/04
The shocker's out...another All-Star will win a million dollars, and it's the fans' vote that counts! Another live show from New York brings Jeff and the castaways back together to delve further into their lives and experiences after the show.

Results of America's Tribal Council
Best Fight: Jon gets tongue-lashed by Rupert after finding out Jon was the one who voted against him (Pearl Islands)
Sexiest Male: Colby Donaldson (Australia)
Hottest Female: Amber Brkich (Australia)
Greatest Villain: Jon Dalton (Pearl Islands)
Greatest Survivor Moment: Rupert steals shoes (Pearl Islands)
Favorite All-Star: Rupert Boneham (Pearl Islands)