DESPITE REPORTS that six Italian soldiers who served in the Balkans
died of leukemia on their return home, Pentagon spokesman Ken Bacon said
that the U.S. military has found “no link between depleted uranium munitions
and any illness.”
Earlier on Thursday, European
Commission President Romano Prodi said that European countries wanted to
know the truth about the impact of depleted uranium in the Balkans.
Italy had demanded that NATO discuss
the issue at the alliance’s political committee meeting on Tuesday, the
Italian foreign ministry said.
Last week, Italy said it would
investigate illnesses among its soldiers who were deployed in Kosovo after
NATO’s 78-day bombing campaign in 1999.
The announcement set off a chain
reaction, with Spain, Portugal, Turkey and Finland saying they would screen
their Kosovo veterans.
U.S. CITES STUDIES
According to the U.S. military,
several Pentagon and independent health studies on Gulf War illness, including
one released last month, found no connection between depleted uranium rounds
fired during the Gulf War and any adverse health effects reported by Gulf
War vets, NBC’s Jim Miklaszewski reported.
Bacon said that depleted
uranium used in some armor-piercing rounds contains 40 percent less radioactivity
than natural uranium. Depleted uranium rounds fired from A-10 planes and
depleted uranium armor in Abrams tanks are actually encased in steel, he
said.
Uranium is best known in its enriched
form, which is used for nuclear power plant fuel and in nuclear weapons.
A byproduct of the enrichment process is depleted uranium which, as its
name implies, is depleted of much of its radioactivity. Because depleted
uranium is extremely dense, it is unusually effective in penetrating conventional
tank armor.
A 1999 Rand Corp. review of scientific
literature on uranium found no studies indicating adverse health effects
on humans from exposure to or ingestion of uranium compounds. Rand, which
analyzes national security issues for the Pentagon, recommended more research
on the subject because the use of depleted uranium munitions is expected
to grow.
Of the two major health
concerns associated with depleted uranium in military uses — chemical toxicity
and radiation effects — the toxicity is generally considered to be greater,
Rand said. When a depleted uranium round strikes armor or burns, it produces
uranium dust or aerosol particles, which can be inhaled. Once internalized,
a fraction of the particles dissolve and enter the bloodstream, where most
uranium is excreted from the body through the kidneys.
Pentagon officials acknowledged
there could be a health risk if someone were to inhale depleted uranium.
For that reason, U.S. troops working around an armored vehicle that has
been recently struck by depleted uranium are instructed to wear protective
face masks.
However, Bacon said that even
the “atomized” depleted uranium is normally quickly dispersed and does
not present a health risk over an extended period of time.
ITALY CHASTISED
Bacon specifically refuted claims
by the Italian military that linked depleted uranium rounds to leukemia
in some of its troops.
In one case, the Italians said
that one soldier died of leukemia only three weeks after returning from
a peacekeeping mission in the Balkans. Bacon said there is no evidence
anywhere that links depleted uranium to leukemia, and that leukemia develops
over a longer period of time.
Bacon also said that of 33 American
troops hit by friendly fire during the Gulf war, 15 who actually still
carry depleted uranium shrapnel in their bodies are periodically monitored
and have still shown no ill health effects.
Bacon said that no U.S. troops
serving as peacekeepers in Bosnia or Kosovo have suffered any ill effects
that could be attributed to contact with depleted uranium.
ABOLITION OF WEAPONS
In an interview with Italian state
radio RAI, the European Commission’s Prodi said that even if there was
a minimal risk for soldiers or civilians, the weapons should be abolished.
“And even if this risk was not there, I don’t like the idea of using these
particular weapons,” he said.
Prodi said he was not only
concerned about the “Balkan syndrome” but also about the environmental
damage caused by the wars in Bosnia and Yugoslavia.
“As Commission president, I propose
starting immediate contacts with the governments of Bosnia and Serbia to
discuss pollution and the problems linked to depleted uranium,” he told
the radio.
Italy said that the six soldiers
who died since returning from the Balkans all suffered leukemia. The latest
was a 24-year-old soldier from Sicily who died in November after serving
twice in Bosnia but never in Kosovo.
Doctors have said there is insufficient
evidence to link the deaths to exposure to uranium bullets — used to pierce
armor — but Italian media have claimed the number of deaths is too high
to be coincidental.
Some 60,000 Italian soldiers and
15,000 civilians served in the Balkans during the 1990s.
According to Italian media reports,
NATO used around 31,500 bullets and shells capped with uranium during the
campaign to end Serb repression of ethnic Albanians in Kosovo in 1999.
NBC’s Jim Miklaszewski in Washington,
The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report.