Round 1 
1 CLE - Willie Mays, OF 
2 BKN - Ted Williams, OF 
3 NYN - Hank Aaron, OF 
4 PHA - Al Kaline. OF 
5 PHA via NYA - Ernie Banks, SS 
6 DEA - Johnny Temple, 2b 
7 BAA via CHA - Don Newcombe P 
8 BOA - Frank Sullivan P 
9 SLN - Don Mossi RP 
10 CLA via BAA - Wally Moon, OF 


Round 2 
1 CLE - Jack Harshman, P 
2 BKN - Ray Narleski, RP 
3 NYN Wally Post OF 
4 PHA - Gene Conley, P 
5 CHA via NYA-Dean Stone P 
6 DEA - Vic Power inf/of 
7 CHA - Andy Carey 3b 
8 BOA - Al Smith, OF 
9 SLN - Camilo Pascual P 
10 NYN via BAA - Bob Grim SP 

Round 3 
1. CLE - Bill Sarni, C 
2. BRK - Ray Crone, RP 
3. NYN - Hal Newhouser, RP 
4. PHA - Tom Poholsky, RP 
5. NYA - Vern Law - SP 
6. DEA - Brooks Lawrence - P 
7. CHA -Arnie Portocarrero SP 
8. BOA - Bobby Morgan SS 
9. SLN - Don Hoak 3B 
10. BAA - Jim Hearn P 
 

Round 4 
1. CLE - Windy McCall, RP 
2. BKN - Walker Cooper, C 
3. NYN - Grady Hatton 3B 
4. PHA - George Zuverink P 
5. NYA - Sandy Amoros OF 
6. DEA - Tom Morgan P 
7. CHA - Howie Pollet P 
8. BOA - Vern Thies P 
9. SLN - George Strickland SS 
10. BAA - Johnny Podres, SP 
 
Round 5 
1. CLE - Tom Brewer - P 
2. BKN - Don Johnson - SP 
3. NYN - Joe Cunningham 1B 
4. PHA - Cal Abrams, OF/PH 
5. NYA - Gus Zernial 
6. DEA - Jack Shepard C 
7. CHA - Billy Shantz C 
8. BOA - Bob Greenwood, RP 
9. SLN - Jim Davis SP 
10. BAA- Billy Loe 

Round 6 
1. CLE - Art Ditmar P 
2. BKN - Jim Finigan 3B 
3. NYN - Wally Westlake OF 
4. PHA - Danny O'Connell, IF 
5. NYA - Bill Tuttle C 
6. DEA - Bob Chakales RP 
7. CHA - Gene Baker 2b 
8. BOA - Herm Wehmeier, SP 
9. SLN - John Groth OF 
10. BAA- Morrie Martin -rp 
 
Round 7 
1. CLE - Jim McDonald - P 
2. BKN - Bill Wilson - OF 
3. NYN -  Ted Lepcio  -   IF 
4. PHA - Wayne Belardi - 1B/PH 
5. NYA - Frank House - C 
6. DEA - Mo Burtschy - RP 
7. CHA - Bill Renna - OF 
8. BOA - Chuck Diering - OF 
9. SLN - Billy Cox  IF 
10. BAA- Frank Baumholtz OF 
 

Round 8 
1. CLE - Preston Ward - 1B 
2. BKN - Danny Schell - OF 
3. NYN - Dick Littlefield - P 
4. PHA - Gil Coan  - OF 
5. NYA - Frank Bolling - 2B 
6. DEA - Ed Lopat - p 
7. CHA - Vic Raschi -P 
8. BOA - Ray Katt - C 
9. SLN - Joe Tipton - C 
10. BAA- Joe Demaestri 
 
 Round 9 
1. BKN- Alex Grammas - ss,3b 
2. NYN - Art Fowler RP 
3. PHA - Bill Tremel RP 
4. NYA - Jim Konstanty - P 
5. DEA - Spook Jacobs - 2b 
6. CHA - Billy Hunter - SS 
7. BOA - Harry Agganis - 1B 
8. SLN -  Ed Bailey  C 
9. BAA-  Dick Kryhoski 1B 
 
Round 10 
1. BKN- Wayne Terwilliger - IF 
2. PHA - Jerry Lynch - OF 
4. NYA - Phil Rizzuto - inf 
5. DEA - Bob Skinner - of/1b 
6. CHA - Leo Keily - P 
7. BOA - Max Surkont - P
8. BAA- Rube Walker -c


Round 11

1.  NYA -  Howie Judson - P
2.  DEA -   Billy Consolo - inf
3.  BAA -   Paul Lapalme
4.  NYA -   Tom Alston  1B