Round 1.

1. BAL - Roger Maris - OF
2. CHA Via NYA via CHA- Johnny Podres P
3. DEA- Jack Sanford P
4. BKN- Billy O'Dell P
5. SLN- Joe Cunningham 1B
6. BOA- Ralph Terry P
7. BAL via NYA- Frank Malzone 3b
8. KCA- Don Mcmahon RP
9. CLA- Bob Purkey P
10. NYG- Mike Mccormick P

Round 2

1. BAL- Tony Kubek UT
2. CHA- Bob Cerv OF
3. DEA- Bobby Richardson 2B
4. BKN-Wes Covington OF
5. SLN- Connie Johnson SP
6. BOA - Turk Farrell
7. BKN via NYA- Jim Brosnan P
8. KCA - George Kell - 3B
9. CLA - Charlie Neal - 3B
10. NYG- Billy Loes P

Round 3

1. BAL- Duke Maas P
2. CHA- Junior Gilliam 2B
3. DEA - Dick Drott P
4. BKN - Juan Pizzaro P
5. CHA via SLN - Woodie Held OF
6. BOA- Harry Anderson OF
7. NYA- Billy Muffett P
8. KCA - Eddie Kasko - IF
9. DEA via CLA - Eddie Yost - 3B
10. NYG - Ed Bouchee 1B

Round 4

1. BAL - Ned Garver P
2. CHA via NYA via CHA - Jim Landis CF
3. DEA - Al Pilarcik OF
4. BKN- Gene Freese 3B
5. SLN- Lou Berberet C
6. BOA-Frank Torre,1B
7. NYA-Andy Carey 3B
8. KCA - Roy Campanella - C
9. CLA - Ryne Duren RP
10. NYG - Jack Urban SP

Round 5

1. BAL - Lou Sleater P
2. CHA - Dick Hyde P
3. DEA - Herb Plews INF
4. BKN - Hank Foiles C
5. SLN - George Zuverink RP
6. BOA- Russ Nixon C
7. NYA- Artie Portacarrero P
8. KCA- Von McDaniel P
9. CLA - Hank Sauer OF
10. NYG - Clem Labine P

Round 6
1. BAL - Bud Daley p
2. CHA - JOE NUXHALL -P
3. DEA - Lloyd Merritt P
4. BKN - Billy Gardner IF
5. NYA via SLN- Jim Rivera OF
6. BOA - Lee Walls OF
7. NYA - Hank Bauer OF
8. KCA - Mike Fornieles P
9. CLA - Clint Courtney C
10. NYG - George Crowe 1B

Round 7

1. BAL - Paul LaPalme P
2. CHA - Bobby Thompson OF
3. DEA - Gino Cimoli OF
4. BKN- Joe Demaestri 2B
5. SLN- Bob Speake 1B-OF
6. BOA- Cal Neeman C
7. NYA- Bobby Avila 2B
8. KCA- Granny Hamner SS
9. CLA- Reno Bertoia- MIF
10. NYG- Bud Byerly- P

Round 8
1. BAL- Don Elston P
2. CHA- Don Zimmer IF
3. DEA- Bob Smith P
4. BKN- Jim Hearn P
5. SLN- Ray Boone PH
6. BOA- Gene Baker IF
7. NYA- Rocky Bridges IF
8. KCA- Al Ciccotte P
9. CLA- Bubba Phillips OF
10. NYG- Bob Miller P

Round 9
1. BAL- Jim Busby OF
2. CHA- Pee Wee Reese IF
3. DEA- Larry Raines IF
4. BKN- Tex Clevenger P
5. SLN- Dave Philley OF
6. BOA - Tom Morgan P
7. NYA- Joe Ginsberg C
8. KCA- Frank House
9. CLA- Dick Gernert 1B
10. NYG- Curt Barclay P

Round 10
4. BKN- Bob Porterfield P
5. SLN- Chico Fernandez SS
6. BOA- Mickey Vernon 1B
7. NYA- Danny McDevitt RP
9. CLA- Lou Skizas IF
10. NYG- Hobie Landreth C

Round 11
2. SLN - Bob Bowman OF
3. NYA- Seth Moorehead
4. CLA- Gail Harris 1B
5. SLN- Tim Thompson C