Round 1
1. DEA - Bob Gibson P
2. LAD - Harmon Killebrew 3B
3. BAL - Vida Pinson OF
4. KCA- Jim Perry P
5. SLN - Maury Wills SS
6. SLN - Bob Allison OF
7. BAL - Tito Francona OF-1B
8. SLN - Bill White 1B
9. SLN - Felipe Alou OF
10. BOA - Gil Hodges 1B

Round 2
1. DEA - Bobby Richardson - 2B
2. NYA - Jim O'Toole P
3. SFG - Jackie Brandt OF
4. BAL - Turk Lown P
5. SLN - Roger Craig P
6. KCA - Jim Owens P
7. CHA - Gus Triandos- C
8. CLA - Ernie Broglio- P
9. KCA via BAL - Larry Sherry P
10. BOA - George Altman - OF

Round 3
1. DEA - Mike Fornieles - RP
2. LAD - Jim Coates - P
3. SFG - Jerry Walker - P
4. CHA- Jack Fisher - P
5. SLN - Hal W. Smith - C
6. KCA - Hal R. Smith - C
7. CHA - Chuck Stobbs -P
8. CLA - Russ Snyder - OF
9. BAL - Dick Gernert 1b
10. BOA - Norm Siebern - 1B

Round 4
1. DEA - Charlie Maxwell - OF
2. LAD - Gene Freese - 3B
3. SFG - John Buzzhart - P
4. NYA - Gary Geiger - OF
5. SLN - Tom Brewer - P
6. KCA - Al Pilarcik - OF
7. CHA - Ike Delock - P
8. CLA - Fred Green - P
9. BAL - M. Bridges - Rp
10. BOA - Billy Martin, 2B

Round 5
1. DEA - Harry Chiti C
2. LAD - Barry Latman - P
3. SFG - Don Farrarese - P
4. NYA - Johnny Klippstein - P
5. SLN - Elmer Singleton - P
6. KCA - Frank Thomas - DH
7. CHA - Humberton Robinson - P
8. CLA - Willie Jones - 3B
9. BAL - Pete Burnside - rp
10. BOA - Dutch Dotterer

Round 6
1. DEA - Bobby Locke RP
2. LAD - Ed Bressoud SS
3. SFG - Lou Berberet C
4. NYA - Bob Cerv OF
5. SLN - Tex Clevenger P
6. KCA - Billy Loes RP
7. CHA - Earl Averill - C
8. CLA - Don Cardwell - P
9. BAL - Dave Philly -
10. BOA - Joe Koppe, IF

Round 7
1. DEA - Joe Demaestri SS
2. LAD - Al Worthington P
3. SFG - Jim Baxes IF
4. NYA - Dave Sisler P
5. SLN - Earl Torgeson 1B-PH
6. KCA - Bob Anderson P
7. CHA - Don Demeter CF
8. CLA - Russ Nixon C
9. BAL - Frank Baumann P
10. BOA - Lee Walls - OF

Round 8
1. DEA - Dick Williams - UTL
2. LAD - Kent Hadley - 1B
3. SFG - Paul Foytack P
4. NYA - Al Dark
5. KCA - Billy Klaus IF
6. CHA - Dale Long -1b
7. CLA - Hal Woodeschick P
8. BAL - Hobie Landrith c
9. BOA - Jack Harshmann, P

Round 9
1. DEA - Tom Sturdivant RP
2. LAD - Ron Fairly OF
3. SFG - Jerry Casale P
4. NYA - Billy Gardner IF
5. KCA - Gene Stephens OF
6. CHA - ALEX KELLNER -P
7. CLA - Frank Torre -1B
8. BAL - Jack Meyer
9. BOA - Bill Fischer, P

Round 10
1. DEA - Ed Fitz Gerald - C
2. LAD - Brooks Lawrence - P
3. SFG - Sparky Anderson - 2B
4. NYA - Vic Wertz - 1B
5. CHA - Fay Thoneberry of -1b
6. CLA - Bob Turley - P
7. BOA - Gene Oliver - C

 Round 11
1. LAD - Bubba Phillips - 3B/OF
2. SFG - Walt Moryn - OF
3. NYA - Bob Schmidt - C
4. CLA - Alex Grammas - SS
5. NYA - Andre Rodgers - SS