Round 1
1. Los Angeles - Juan Marichal, P
2. Chicago NL - Carl Yastrzemski, OF
3. Boston - Billy Williams, OF
4. Detroit - Leon Wagner OF
5. St Louis - Joe Torre C
6. Los Angeles Ron Perranoski P
7. Kansas City -Dick McAuliffe, ss/2b
8. Baltimore - John Blanchard C
9. Philadelphia Terry Fox P
10. San Francisco Willie Davis OF

Round 2
1. Los Angeles - Zoilo Versalles, SS
2. Chicago NL - Albie Pearson - OF
3. Detroit - Floyd Robinson OF
4. Detroit - Wayne Causey IF
5. St Louis - Don Demeter OF
6. New York AL - Ron Fairly OF
7. Kansas City - Billy Hoeft P
8. Baltimore - Bobby Bolin P
9. Philadelphia - Gary Bell P
10. San Francisco - Lee Thomas 1B

Round 3
1. New York AL - Dick Howser SS
2. Chicago NL - Don Lee -P
3. Boston - Jim Archer - P
4. Detroit - Wes Stock P
5. St Louis - Al McBean RP
6. New York AL - Ken McBride P
7. Kansas City - Frank Bolling 2B
8. Baltimore - Joe Cunningham of-1B
9. Kansas City - Stan Williams P
10. San Francisco - Steve Bilko 1B

Round 4
1. Los Angeles - Jack Baldschun P
2. Chicago NL - Art Fowler P
3. Boston - Earl Averill C,OF
4. Detroit - Lindy McDaniel RP
5. St Louis - Jim Pagliaroni C
6. Chicago NL Jerry Adair -INF
7. Kansas City - Gene Green C/RF
8. Baltimore - Frank Malzone 3rd
9. Boston - Barry Latman - P
10. San Francisco - Dick Brown C

Round 5
1. Los Angeles - Jose Pagan SS
2. Chicago NL - Frank Funk -p
3. Boston Barney Schultz - RP
4. Detroit - Harvey Kuenn IF
5. St Louis - Don Schwall - P
6. Philadelphia Jim King OF/C
7. New York (AL) Hillman
8. Baltimore W.Herzog OF
9. Philadelphia - Ron Kline P
10. San Francisco - Ken I Hunt OF/2B

Round 6
1. Los Angeles - Gus Triandos C
2. Chicago NL - Chuck Cottier INF
3. Boston - Bob Skinner - OF
4. Detroit - Joe Pignatano - C
5. St Louis - Bob Miller RP
6. New York AL - Dick Lemay P
7. Kansas City - Minnie Minoso OF
8. Chicago NL - Clay Dalrymple C
9. Philadelphia - Tony Cloninger P
10. San Francisco - Chuck Schilling

Round 7
1. Los Angeles - Clem Labine P
2. Chicago NL - Dale Long -1B
3. Boston - Bubba Phillips 3B
4. Detroit - Tom Sturdivant - P
5. St Louis - Jerry Kindall - IF
6. New York AL - Warren Hacker - P
7. Boston via Kansas City - Joe McClain
8. Baltimore - Chet Nichols P
9. Philadelphia - Don Ferrarese P
10. San Francisco - Roland Sheldon

Round 8
1. Los Angeles - Jake Wood 2B
2. Chicago NL Johnny Temple -2b
3. Boston - Carroll Hardy - OF
4. Detroit - Paul Foytack P
5. St Louis - Lee Walls OF
6. New York AL - Jim Coates
7. New York AL - Don Zimmer
8. Baltimore - D.O'Connell
9. Philadelphia - Bill Tuttle OF/UT
10. San Francisco- Joe Koppe IF

Round 9
1. Los Angeles - Hal Reniff, P
4. Detroit - Andy Carey 3B
5. St Louis - Camilo Carreon C
6. Kansas City via New York AL - Jim Schaffer C
7. Kansas City - Early Wynn RP
8. Baltimore - Ted Bowsfield P
9. Philadelphia - Charley Neal IF
10. San Francisco- Dick Bertell C

Round 10
1. Los Angeles - Vic Wertz 1B
4. Detroit - George Thomas OF
5. St Louis - Bob Allen P
6. New York AL - Dick Stigman P
7. Kansas City - Bobby Malkmus IF
8. Baltimore  - Chuck Hinton OF
9. Philadelphia - Joe Nuxhall P
10.San Francisco - Jack Fisher P

Round 11
New York AL - Willie Kirkland RF
Kansas City - Ted Kluszewski PH
Baltimore - Mike Roarke C
Philadelphia - Lee Maye OF