Round 1
 
Mets    - Bill White 1B Cardinals
Indians - Milt Pappas SP Los Angeles
 
Round 2
Mets    - Bill Monbouquette Baltimore
Indians - Ernie Banks 1B Kansas City
 
Round 3
Mets   - Bill Virdon CF 
Indians - Don Demeter OF
 
Round  4
Mets  - Yogi Berra C 
Indians - Bob Buhl SP
 
Round 5
Mets - Vern Law P
Indians - Dick Stigman P
 
Round 6
Mets - Joe Gibbon P 
Indians - Bob Bruce P
 
Round 7
Mets - Bill Henry P
Indians -Harvey Haddix P
 
Round 8
Mets - Johnny Klippstein P 
Indians - Bob Hendley P
 
Round 9
Mets - Lee Maye OF
Indians - Roy Sievers OF
 
Round 10
Mets - Charlie Neal INF 
Indians - Clay Dalrymple C
 
Round 11
Mets - Don Nottebart P 
Indians - Chico Fernandez SS
 
Round 12
Mets - Frank Bolling 2B
Indians - Harvey Kuenn 3B
 
Round 13
Mets - Jose Pegan SS 
Indians - Nellie Fox 2B
 
Round 14
Mets - Ed Bailey C 
Indians - Hector Lopez OF
 
Round 15
Mets - Ed Rakow SP 
Indians - Don Elston RP