1922 Eddie Collins (7) CLE-PIN 80 157 15
1921 Frankie Frisch CIN 82 160 29
1920 Eddie Collins (6) CLE 84 160 20
1919 Joe Gedeon DOD 89 161 13
1918 Dean Shean DOD 85 162 17
1917 Eddie Collins (5) CLE 82 158 19
1916 Nap Lajoie (4) DOD 81 159 26
1915 Eddie Collins (5) CLE 82 148 26
1914 Eddie Collins (4) CLE 82 153 22
1913 Eddie Collins (3) CLE 83 154 21
1912 Johnny Evers PIN 81 156 33
1911 Miller Huggins CLE 78 162 32
1910 Eddie Collins (2) BOA 80 155 31
1909 Eddie Collins BOA 73 159 42
1908 Otto Knabe CIN 80 159 28
1907 Hobe Ferris (3) PIN 81 153 26
1906 Nap Lajoie (3) NYA 84 161 23
1905 Nap Lajoie (2) NYA 77 158 32
1904 Hobe Ferris (2) PIN 84 142 17
1903 Hobe Ferris PIN 78 161 32
1902 Claude Richey CHA 77 143 24
1901 Nap Lajoie NYN 74 162 43
(Number in parenthesis is number of times player has repeated as winner of that category.)
