| Pitcher of the Year Award |
| Year Player W-L ERA Team Owner |
| 1901 Al Orth 26- 9 2.33 Cleveland Blues Jeff K 1902 Bill Bernhard 25- 9 1.76 Pittsburgh Pirates Craig 1903 Deacon Phillippe 27- 8 1.53 St Louis Cardinals Rene 1904 Chief Bender 26-10 2.05 St Louis Cardinals Rene 1905 Christy Mathewson 30-10 1.88 Pittsburgh Craig/Scott 1906 Mordicai Brown 26- 8 1.88 Detroit Tigers Joe 1907 Orval Overall 28-11 2.29 Cleveland Naps Jeff K. 1908 Frank Smith 24-11 1.71 Boston Red Sox Thomas 1909 Harry Gaspar 27- 7 2.11 Brooklyn Superbas Jeff R 1910 Russ Ford 26-7 1.86 New York Highlanders Steve 1911 Christy Mathewson (2) 25-12 2.19 New York Highlanders Steve 1912 Larry Cheney 29-8 2.24 Detroit Tigers Joe 1913 Walter Johnson 28-12 2.12 Cincinnati Reds Tim 1914 Ray Caldwell 23-9 2.16 Pittsburgh Pirates Scott 1915 Dick Rudolph 26-8 2.34 Brooklyn Dodgers Jeff R. 1916 Ferdie Schupp 17-8 1.01 StLouis/Yankees Rene/Steve 1917 Pete Alexander 28-10 2.04 Philly A's Brian 1918 Walter Johnson (2) 28-11 2.07 Cincinnati Tim 1919 Hippo Vaughn 25-9 2.23 PHA/NYA Brian/Steve 1920 Stan Coveleski 28-4 2.73 NY Yankees Steve 1921 Wilbur Cooper 29-8 3.28 NY Yankees Steve 1922 Red Faber 27-13 3.34 Cincinnati Reds Tim 1951 Saul Rogovin 22- 8 3.00 New York Yankees Steve 1952 Mike Garcia 22- 9 3.06 Baltimore Orioles Joe 1953 Vic Raschi 19- 7 3.17 Baltimore Orioles Joe 1954 Bob Turley 25- 5 2.27 Philadelphia A's Brian 1955 Billy Pierce 26- 1 2.27 Philadelphia A's Brian 1956 Tom Brewer 25-8 2.78 Cleveland Indians Jeff K 1957 Jack Urban 19-1 2.46 New York Giants Raul 1958 Sam Jones 25-7 3.30 Boston Red Sox Jeff R. 1959 Vern Law 24-10 2.44 Baltimore Orioles Joe 1960 Mike McCormick 21-8 2.80 San Fran Giants Raul 1961 Mike McCormick (2) 27-7 3.45 San Fran Giants Raul 1962 Sandy Koufax 21-5 2.16 St Louis Cardinals Rene 1963 Juan Marichal 21-6 2.11 Los Angeles Dodgers Dave 1964 Sandy Koufax 24-5 2.10 St Louis Cardinals Rene 1965 Stu Miller 8-2 0.77 Baltimore Orioles Joe 1966 Jim Nash 20-4 2.26 Baltimore Orioles Joe 1967 Phil Ortega 23-4 2.54 Chicago Cubs Larry 1968 Denny McLain 26-9 2.04 Boston Hal 1969 Mike Cuellar 25-11 2.48 Philadelphia Scott 1970 Fritz Peterson 23-9 3.33 Chicago Cubs Larry 1971 Clay Kirby 25-9 3.10 California Angels Raul 1972 Steve Carlton 27-5 1.86 New York Yankees Steve |
 |
|