| Wild Cards |
| Season Division Team Record Pct Owner |
| 1901 Cobb St Louis Cardinals 87-75 .537 Rene Bernard 1902 Cobb New York Giants 97-65 .599 Steve Feldheim 1903 Cobb Pittsburgh Pirates 100-62 .617 Craig 1904 Mathewson New York Highlanders 100-62 .617 Steve Feldheim 1905 Mathewson Pittsburgh Pirates 96-66 .593 Craig/Scott 1906 Mathewson Philadelphia A's 94-68 .580 Brian 1907 Mathewson Brooklyn Superbas 91-71 .562 Jeff Richards 1908 Cobb Cincinnati Reds 97-65 .599 Tim 1909 Mathewson New York Highlanders 91-71 .562 Steve Feldheim 1910 Cobb Cincinnati Reds 92-70 .568 Tim 1911 Cobb Cincinnati Reds 91-71 .562 Tim 1912 Cobb Cincinnati Reds 103-59 .636 Tim 1913 Mathewson Pittsburgh Pirates 92-70 .568 Scott 1914 Mathewson Pittsburgh Pirates 94-68 .580 Scott 1915 Cobb Boston Red Sox 87-75 .537 Lawrence 1916 Cobb Cincinnati Reds 92-70 .568 Tim 1917 Mathewson Philadelphia A's 97-65 .599 Brian 1918 Mathewson Philadelphia A's 91-71 .562 Brian 1919 Mathewson Cleveland Indians 88-74 .543 Robert Fitts 1920 Cobb New York Giants 87-75 .537 Lawrence 1921 Mathewson Philadelphia A's 97-65 .599 Brian 1922 Mathewson New York Yankees 95-67 .586 Steve Feldheim 1923 Mathewson Pittsburgh Pirates 90-72 .556 Jim Froelick 1951 Cobb New York Yankees 91-71 .562 Steve Feldheim 1952 Mathewson Detroit Tigers 85-77 .525 Stan 1953 Mathewson Boston Redsox 87-75 .537 Jared 1954 Mathewson New York Giants 90-72 .556 Raul 1955 Mathewson New York Yankees 101-61 .623 Steve Feldheim 1956 Mathewson Kansas City A's 93-69 .574 Brian 1957 Mathewson New York Yankees 108-54 .667 Steve Feldheim 1958 Mathewson Baltimore Orioles 97-65 .599 Joe 1959 Cobb St Louis Cardinals 92-70 .568 Rene 1960 Mathewson Baltimore Orioles 91-71 .562 Joe 1961 Mathewson Baltimore Orioles 100-62 .617 Joe 1962 Mathewson Baltimore Orioles 96-66 .593 Joe 1963 Mathewson Los Angeles Dodgers 105-57 .648 Dave 1964 Mathewson Los Angeles Dodgers 103-59 .636 Dave 1965 Cobb St Louis Cardinals 96-66 .593 Rene 1966 Cobb St Louis Cardinals 92-70 .568 Rene 1967 Cobb Kansas City A's 99-63 .611 Brian 1968 Cobb Detroit Tigers 89-73 .549 None 1969 Cobb Chicago Cubs 102-60 .630 Larry D 1970 Cobb New York Yankees 97-65 .599 Steve Feldheim 1971 Cobb Boston Red Sox 97-65 .599 Jeff Richards 1972 Mathewson New York Mets 107-55 .660 Billy Stroppel |
 |