TREASURES OF THE KASHMIR SMAST:

Unpublished Bronzes from the Alxon Hunnic Period-  Kashmir Smast, Mardan, NWFP, Pakistan

 

By Waleed Ziad

 

Enlargement of Em. 1a

 

PRESENTATION

 

Note: Robert Gobl’s Dokumente Zur Geschichte Der Iranischen Hunnen in Baktrien und Indien (hereinafter referred to as Hunnen) volumes have been employed as the primary reference.  ‘Em.’ will generally refer to emissions listed in Gobl Hunnen, or to the emissions introduced herein.

 

Part I: The Hephthalite Lunar Bull tamgha: The Alxon Investiture Senmurv AE and related coins

 

The first part of this article focuses on five (and one additional AE from Bannu) unpublished varieties of Hephthalite coins from the Kashmir Smast horde, which feature the Alxon Lunar Bull tamgha, and which therefore may be attributed to the Alxon period, during which time the tamgha was commonly used on AR and AE coinage. (The tamgha is found on certain Nazek issues, but according to Alram, may have been adopted by the Nazek Huns from the coinage of Narendra in Kabul).[1]

 

The Hephthalite Lunar Bull tamgha, discussed by Gobl, (he refers to it as the as S1 in Volume IV of Hunnen), represents the frontal view of a bull.[2]  Its horns form the top crescent portion of the tamgha, implying links between early medieval lunar symbolism and the sacred bull.  The lower part of the tamgha, the legs and body of the cow, is supposedly Indian in origin, being derived from the Nandipada-triratna.[3]

 

In Gobl Hunnen, the first appearance of the Lunar Bull tamgha is during what he refers to as the period of the Alxon Anonymer Clanchef.  Given the fact that the first coinage of the early Clan-Chiefs closely imitated Sasanian prototypes, it is likely that the varieties presented in this article were issued after this period, perhaps during the reign of Khingila or later by which time Alxon Hunnic coinage had assumed particular features, characterized by a unique artistic style and the presence of certain symbols.  

 

The weight and fabric of all five varieties conforms to the Kashmir Smast standard, small crudely struck coins generally ranging from 0.5 to 1.3 grams, similar to what Mitchiner refers to as the Hunnic ¼ drachm.[4]

 

1. The Alxon ‘Duck’ (Senmurv)

 

 

a.                   AE Unit

1.17 g. / 14.1x13.9 mm.

 

 

 

 

b.         AE Unit

1.13 g. / 14.7x15.3 mm.

 

 

 

c.         AE Unit

0.84 g. / 1.30x1.22 mm.

 

 

d.         AE Unit

0.87 g. / 1.89x1.30 mm.

 

 

 

e.         AE Unit

0.94 g. / 1.94x1.23 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.: Senmurv right holding pearls and streamers

Rev.: Six akshara Brahmi legend

 

The author’s collection contains five specimens of a small, round, AE coin originally referred to in the Peshawar bazaars as the ‘duck’ coin.  The symbolism and artistry on this rare investiture piece make it a historically significant and artistically unusual find.

 

The obverse depicts a duck-like bird holding a string of pearls in its beak, attached to two royal ribbons / bands.  The Senmurv, a mythical bird often depicted on Hunnic coins and found on a series of Hunnic countermarks (KM 1-12 / c in Gobl Hunnen), is often pictured carrying a string of pearls in its beak (KM 11 a, for example), or a string of pearls attached to two royal bands.  The string of pearls and attached bands were the two prime symbols of investiture during the late Sasanian and Hunnic periods. [5]  According to Persianate / Hunnic mythology, the Senmurv is the carrier of the investiture symbols, which it bestows upon each ruler.[6]

 

The bands, a device originally found on Sasanian coins, were adopted by various Hunnic dynasties in their silver drachms as well as in their AE coinage, including the Alxon, Kidara, Nezak, and Turk Shahi.   In late Sasanian coinage, prior to the Hunnic invasions into Eastern Iran, we find depictions of kings on AR drachms wearing necklaces (strings of pearls) to which are attached two striped flowing bands.  Such bands also form part of many Hunnic crowns, affixed to the rear portion of the diadem.

 

The Senmurv, or Simurgh, in ancient Persia is normally depicted as a griffin-like creature, part mammal and part bird, with a curved beak, protruding tongue, and two arms in addition to wings, or as a winged dog with fish scales.  It is said to be the union of the earth, sea, and sky.  Later, in Islamic mythology, it features in Firdausi’s Shahnameh, composed for the Ghaznawid court in the 11th century.  The Simurgh takes on great metaphysical connotations in Farid al din Attar’s classic, The Conference of the Birds where it represents the divine form.

 

Here it takes the form of a simple duck like bird, with a straight beak and small rounded body.  This is an unusual and perhaps unique style of representing of this mythical creature.

 

In the upper left field of the obverse is the Hephthalite Lunar Bull symbol. 

 

The reverse legend contains six Brahmi aksharas in two lines, in an early medieval Kushano-Sasanian / Kidarite style of Brahmi.

 

The two line legend reads:[7]

 

Ja Ya Ti

Dha Rma H

 

The legend reads Jayati Dharma, meaning ‘the victorious law’.  This particular legend also appears on a Hunnic AR drachm in the Ashmolean published by Gobl.

 

The title Jayati or Jayatu is found generally on Peshawar minted issues of Toramana (Gobl Hunnen Em. 108-109), Mihirakula (Gobl Hunnen Em. 134-136), and Narendra (Gobl Hunnen Em. 138, 174, 176).  The reading of two of Khingila’s coins (Gobl Hunnen Em. 77 and 82) may potentially read Jayati but this is not conclusive.

 

Toramana is referred to by title, Jayatu Bayasa (or Vayasa).  Mihirakula is referred to both as Jayatu Mihirakula or Jayatu Vrsadhvaja.  On Narendra’s coins Jayatu is followed by the emperor’s name Narendra or Narana.[8]

 

The use of the title Jayati therefore suggests that the coin may have been struck during the reign of Toramana or Mihirakula. 

 

An alternative reading suggests that the ‘rma’ on the second line is instead a ‘kla’, in which case the legend would read:

 

Dha Kla H

 

with Dhakla being the name of a potential ruler or clan. 

 

The legend ‘Dha Rma’ or ‘Dha Kla’ also appears on the reverse of a number of Kidarite style AE units from the Kashmir Smast hoard, to be presented in an upcoming article.

 

 

2.  The Alxon Running Horse

 

 

a.                   AE Unit

0.46 g. / 14.4x6.4 mm.

 

 

 

b.         AE Unit

0.54 g / 10.1x9.2 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.: Horse galloping right

Rev.: Lunar Bull Tamgha

 

Two specimens of an unpublished anepigraphic AE unit were found in the hoard.  These small rectangular coins feature a highly stylized, crudely rendered galloping horse on the obverse.  Since both specimens are not centered on the flan, only the forepart of the horse is visible.  The legs of the horse are bent unnaturally three times, with the foot pointing upward, in a running motion. 

 

The reverse depicts simply the Alxon Lunar Bull tamgha within a square border.

 

This particular type of horse image has never been recorded on any Hunnic coins, and does not resemble any horse images found on coins of the period from neighboring kingdoms.  Without additional historical evidence, it is difficult to speculate further on the nature of the piece.

 

3.         Two tamghas: Lunar Bull Tamgha and Double ‘Bull legs’ Tamgha AE Unit

 

 

a.         0.61 g. / 10.3x10.0 mm.

 

 

 

b.         0.65 g. / 11.8x12.2 mm.

 

 

 

c.         0.59 g. / 11.9x11.0 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.: Double ‘Bull’s Legs’ tamgha

Rev.: Lunar Bull tamgha

 

Three specimen of a small round AE, were found in the hoard.

 

The obverse features an Alxon Lunar Bull tamgha in a circular beaded border.

 

The reverse features a hithertofore unpublished tamgha in a circular beaded border, which appears to be a derivation of the Hephthalite Lunar Bull tamgha.  The bottom portion is identical to the Lunar Bull tamgha, but the top portion is a mirror image of the bottom portion.

 

We may assume in this case, following Gobl’s lead, that the double crescent tamgha is a local tamgha of the principality, while the Lunar Tamgha represents allegiance to an Alxon overlord.  The presence of a number of coins in the hoard with different busts on the obverse and on the reverse may signify a similar relationship.

 

4.         Double Crescent Tamgha (from Bannu hoard) AE Unit

1.94 g. / 1.70x1.68 mm.

 

 

 

 

 

Obv.: Bust of king facing right or 2/3 right, with a crescent in front of the bust, and a headdress (?) resembling a rectangle.  The bust resembles those of Em. 27 in Gobl Hunnun. 

Rev.: Double Crescent tamgha surrounded by round beaded border. 

 

While not related to the Kashmir Smast hoard, I am presenting a coin acquired in 1998 in Bannu (NWFP, Pakistan) from a hoard of small Kidarite and related AE coins.  It is a larger coin, weighing 1.94 grams, the only one of this size / style found in the hoard.  The other coins in the hoard were varieties of Gobl Hunnen Em. 25-27.  While the previous emission presented above features a tamgha formed of two lower portions of the Lunar Bull tamgha, this coin features a tamgha made up of two top portions of the Lunar Bull tamgha, i.e. two crescents facing different directions connected by a line. 

 

Whether there is indeed a connection between the two tamghas is a matter of speculation in the absence of further information.  The tamgha also somewhat resembles the tamgha used in the civic AEs of the principality of Benaken in 6th to 8th century Sogdiana.[9]  (The Benaken tamgha is composed of two crescents connected by two lines rather than one line.) Sogd was occupied by the Huns during the early medieval period, and the classic tamgha of Sogd has appeared in Alxon Hunnic coinage (listed by Gobl as Tamgha 2, on Em. 33-34, and on drachms of the successors of Shahi Goboziko in Kabul).[10]  Again, any connection is purely speculative.

 

The lower part of the reverse indicates that this coin is overstruck, or that a weak counterstamp has been applied.

 

5.         Two Lunar Bull Tamghas AE Unit

0.59 g. / 11.0x10.6 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv: Alxon Lunar Bull tamgha in a square beaded border.

Rev.: Alxon Lunar Bull tamgha.  There are two undecipherable crudely rendered aksharas, one on each side of the tamgha, both of which resemble inverted ‘U’s.

 

One specimen, a small thin square AE, was found in the hoard.

 

A potential reading is as follows.  This reading must be substantiated with a better specimen, and it is also likely the legend is corrupted:

 

Ga Ga or Ga Ta

 

 

6.         AE Unit

0.86 g / 11.3x11.0 mm.

 

 

Obv.:      Off-center crowned bust left (?)

Rev.:      Lunar Bull Tamgha, two undecipherable aksharas one each side

 

A better specimen is required to determine the true nature of the obverse design.

 

Part II: The Solar Wheel

 

In Indic mythology, the wheel symbol is used to connote the solar wheel, or dharmacakra (the wheel of life).  The solar wheel image has been employed in Alxon, Nazek, and Turk Shahi coins.  With time, suggests Gobl, the wheel in the Alxon series becomes closer to a flower or star.[11]

 

Stylistically, Em. 7 below can without doubt be attributed to the Alxon period. Em. 8 and 9, however, are rendered in slightly different style.  However, among Hunnic coins the solar wheel symbols below are found primarily in Alxon coinage.  The wheel is pictured in a variety of contexts, as part of a crown, and with other symbols such as vases and banners, but a reverse design comprised solely of a solar wheel is only found in Alxon coins, based on Gobl and Mitchiner attributions.[12] 

 

7.         Narendra AE Unit

1.02 g. / 14.2x12.0 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.: Narendra or Khingila style ‘tall bust’ bare headed king facing right.  Royal band emanating from neck area. 

Rev.: Flower like solar wheel, a version of Symbole 93 in Gobl Hunnen (with one circle surrounding the wheel rather than two).

 

This crudely struck bronze can clearly be dated to the Alxon period.

 

The Gobl Hunnen Symbole 93 style solar wheel is found in AR and debased varieties of coins issued by Narendra featuring the legend jayatu (Gobl Hunnen 171-173).  Emissions 171-173, according to Gobl, were issued during the Alxon retreat from Gandhara toward the Khyber Pass or the Kurram Valley toward Ghazni.  Emissions 171 to 173 supposedly originate from Peshawar, during the early portion of the retreat.

 

Also, if Gobl is correct in assuming that the more stylized flower like wheels are a later variation of the simple wheel, a Narendra or later Hunnic attribution may be appropriate. 

 

8.         AE Unit

 

 

 

a.         0.55 g. / 13.2x11.9 mm.

 

 

b.                  0.57 g. / 13.7x11.6 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.:      Beardless bust wearing headdress facing right.

Rev.:      Alternative version of solar wheel with ten curved spokes inside single circle.

 

The bust on this and the following coin, due to the crude nature of execution, can not be stylistically linked to any particular period.  The headdress appears similar to the cap like headdress on Gobl Hunnen Em. 139, from the second reign of Mihirakula, but more closely resembles Gobl Hunnen Em. 134-136, Em. 151-153, and 158-159, issued in Mihirakula’s capital of Sakala (Sialkot).[13]

 

While a wheel of this exact type is not listed by Gobl, a similar wheel (Symbole 44) is found on Gobl Hunnen Em. 127 and Em. 128 (issued by Toramana in the vicinity of Sakala, before it became the Alxon capital), and on Em. 177 and Em. 178 (attributed to Toramana and Mihirakula). 

 

The striking of this coin may fall between the early and mid part of Mihirakula’s reign.

 

9.         AE Unit

0.72 g. / 13.2x13.2 mm

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Very crudely rendered beardless bust wearing headdress (?) with pointed features, wearing what appears to be a turreted headdress.

Rev.:      Alternative flower type version of solar wheel with seven straight spokes between two circles.

 

This coin is stylistically different from the preceding wheel type.  The headdress appears to be turreted, which would be unusual for a coin from Toramana or Mihirakula’s reign, but a better specimen would be required to ascertain the exact nature of the headdress. 

 

The solar wheel, again most similar to Symbole 44, is more like the flower, which may mean that this was struck toward the end of Mihirakula’s reign or during Narendra’s reign.

 

10.       AE Unit

1.20 g. / 14.2x9.0 mm

 

Obv.:      Trident with a dot on either side

Rev.:      Solar wheel with six straight spokes surrounded by beaded circle

 

This coin is not minted in the Kashmir Smast standard, and is of a thick, dumpy fabric.  A small number of unpublished coins in this fabric were found at the cave. 

 

The obverse features a trident (trishula) type tamgha.  The trident or trishula, a symbol of Lord Shiva, is the second most important emblem of Shaivites after nandi.  It signifies the three fundamental shaktis or powers - icha (desire, will, love), kriya (action) and jnana (wisdom).  It features on numerous Hunnic coins, generally those of Toramana and Mihirakula.  The trident featured on this piece resembles Gobl’s Symbole 16, found on Em. 99, a drachm of Toramana, in which it appears in front of the ruler’s bust.

 

The solar wheel depicted on the reverse, surrounded by a beaded circle, is most similar to Gobl’s Symbole 44, found on Gobl Em. 120-125, 127-132, and 154-155, all bronzes of Mihirakula and Toramana from the central Punjab, in particular from the capital at Sakala.

 

This emission may then be attributed to either of the two rulers.

 

Part III: Stylistic Similarities to Alxon Portraits

 

In addition to the coins above, there are a handful of other anepigraphic varieties in the hoard which can be stylistically linked to the Alxon period.  The link is based primarily on the style of the bust of each ruler pictured, and is detailed below.

 

Group I: The Seated Ardoksho Coins

 

Four varieties feature the Goddess Ardoksho on the reverse.  Ardoksho, often associated with Lakshmi, is the Persian / Indic Goddess of plenty and fortune.  She is depicted in early Kushan coinage standing holding cornucopiae and a bow representing the harvest and the hunt.  In later Kushan and Kushano-Sasanian coins (AE and AR), Ardoksho is depicted nimbate, seated on a throne cross legged. 

 

While I plan to delve deeper into this issue, it appears that a disproportionate number of the unpublished Kashmir Smast feature Ardoksho on the reverse.  In fact, apart from the fire altar, a depiction of Ardoksho seated on a lion or a throne is the most common reverse image.  While a number of Kushano-Sasanian / Kushan imitation dumpy coins found in the Kashmir Smast feature Ardoksho, there are additional gods and goddesses found on these including Shiva, Ahuramazd (above altars), and others.  Kidarite and Alxon imitations, as well as unpublished dumpy Kushano-Sasanian imitation coins, of the Kashmir Smast feature Ardoksho.  It is possible that Ardoksho was a preferred deity in the Kashmir Smast principality.

 

It is also worth noting that this particular Kushan style depiction of Ardoksho does not appear on any Alxon coins recorded by Gobl, Mitchiner, or Alram, but does appear on earlier Kidara and Kushano-Sasanian pieces from the Kashmir Smast.

 

11.

 

 

a.                   AE Unit

0.60 g. / 15.0x13.2 mm

 

 

 

b.                  AE Unit

0.94 g. / 14.2x13.2 mm.

 

 

 

 

c.                   AE Unit

0.94 g. / 14.2x13.2 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.: Bare headed bust of beardless ruler facing right with unkempt short hair, wearing a diadem surmounted by a crescent; two streamers behind bust

Rev.: Ardoksho seated facing

 

Two pieces of this type have been discovered in the hoard.  The reasons for the attribution to the Alxon period are as follows:

a) The diadem and crescent are most often associated with the Kidara and Alxon, originating with Yezdgard I, and;

b) The artistic style / certain portrait features, with a combination of short hair and lack of facial hair are similar to the portraits on a number of Alxon seals (e.g. Seals 30 and 31 in Gobl Hunnen). 

 

Small Kidarite bronzes from Gandhara (Bannu) picturing busts with crescent headdresses tend to depict kings with long hair.  The execution of this piece, for the Kashmir Smast hoard, is of a high quality. 

 

12.

 

 

a.         AE Unit

0.64 g. / 12.3x11.9 mm.

 

 

 

c.                   AE Unit

0.71 g. / 12.7x10.8 mm.

 

 

 

Obv.:      Bare headed bust of beardless ruler facing right with close cut hair, wearing diadem.

Rev.:      Ardoksho seated facing

 

Two pieces of this type have been found in the hoard.  Again, like the previous piece, the link to the Alxon period is stylistic.  The rendition of seated Ardoksho is superb for the series, and finer than most Kushano-Sasanian and Kushan prototypes.

 

The portrait on Emission 11b. appears to be nimbate.

 

13.       Rma’ or ‘Kla’ AE Unit

0.51 g / 12.9x12.0 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Bare headed bust of beardless ruler right wearing diadem (stylistically different from above and crudely rendered).  Brahmi akshara behind bust

Rev.:      Ardoksho seated facing

 

The flan is thinner than the previous varieties.  The akshara on the obverse may be read as:

 

Rma or Kla

 

14.       Ha Ra’ AE Unit

0.60 g / 11.9x11.0 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.  Two Brahmi aksharas

Rev.:      Crude Ardoksho seated facing

 

The legend on this coin most probably reads:

 

Ha Ra

 

This legend appears again in Emission 19 below.  The legend may be either a royal name / clan name, or a reference to Lord Shiva, who was the patron deity of a number of Hunnic Alxon rulers.

 

 

Group II: Other Varieties

 

 

15.        AE Unit

0.52 g. / 12.2x12.0 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Tall bust, beardless, close cut hair, facing right, wearing diadem; crude undecipherable legend in front of bust reduced to dashes.

Rev.:      Stylized fire altar with protruding flames. 

 

We may speculate on the religious inclinations of the issuing ruler as a new variety of fire altar is depicted on this emission, distinct from those portrayed on other Sasanian coins, and the Hunnic coins of Siva worshippers who simply imitated the device.  This novel form of altar may indicate that the issuer of the coin held Zoroastrian beliefs.

 

16.       AE Unit

            0.68 g. / 14.7x12.9 mm.

 

 

 

Enlargement of Em. 16

 

Obv.:      Tall bust of Khingila variety, mustached, with mirror in front.

Rev.:      Ghosting of obverse and traces of reverse design.

 

The obverse design of this piece is identical to Gobl Hunnen Em. 70, attributed to Khingila during the first phase after his assumption to the crown.  We can clearly see signs of cranial deformation. We can therefore attribute this emission to the reign of Khingila.

 

Gobl Hunnen Em. 70 is the only Alxon coin featuring a mirror.  The mirror symbol, which originates in Hinduism and takes on further connotations with the advent of Buddhism, signifies right thought.  It represents the dharmakaya, having the aspects of purity, wisdom, and the ability to reflect perfectly without distinction.

 

17.        AE Unit

0.69 g. / 11.1x10.1 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Crowned beardless Alxon style bust right, wearing earring and necklace.  Streamer to the left.

Rev.:      Unidentifiable Zoomorphic figure.

 

Stylistically, based on the beardless portrait, we may tentatively attribute this piece to Khingila or Toramana’s reign.  The reason for presenting this as an Alxon coin is mainly due to the stylistic similarities in portraiture between this and the bust depicted on Em. 17 below, which is believed to be an Alxon period piece as it depicts an unbearded bare headed elongated bust in the Alxon artistic style.

 

The crown on this emission is worth noting.  While the upper portion of the crown is not visible, there is a two pronged protrusion emanating from the left portion.  A better specimen will be required to determine the exact nature of the crown.

 

 

18.        Ha Ra’ AE Unit

0.41 g. / 10.7x9.7 mm.

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Bust facing right.  Degenerate legend in front of bust, comprised of three dashes.

Rev.:      Two akshara legend

 

The weak strike on the obverse makes this piece difficult to attribute stylistically.  The bust is clearly beardless, and appears to be without any pronounced headdress. 

 

The presence of a Brahmi legend narrows the possible time frame to the Kidarite and Alxon periods. 

 

The reverse legend clearly reads:

 

Ha Ra

 

Again, this may signify a title or an abbreviated form of the ruler’s name, or a reference to Lord Shiva, the patron deity of the Alxon rulers in India.  This is identical to legend on Em. 11 above. If the legend is indeed the name or title of the ruler, we could assume that Em. 11 belongs to the same ruler / period as Em. 13.  The question arises as to whether the other Alxon pieces depicting Ardoksho are at all related to Em. 11.  This naturally is a difficult assumption to make given the fact that Ardoksho appears on both Kidarite and Alxon coins from the Kashmir Smast.  It is noteworthy that the two word legend ‘Ha Ra’ does not appear in any of the emissions in Gobl Hunnen.

 

Group III: Seated Lion Variety

 

In addition, there are three varieties of rectangular coins featuring a distinctive seated lion on the obverse / reverse, distantly linked to the lion bronzes of the Scythian ruler Azes II.[14]  The reason for attributing these to the Alxon period is indirect, and based on stylistic elements.  One of three varieties (Em. 20 below) features a seated lion on the reverse and a beardless Alxon bust stylistically similar to the coins of Khingila or Dhala / Dhali.[15] It is a beardless bust with large almond shaped eyes characteristic of the Alxon drachms portraits, and long earrings. 

 

19.        AE Unit

 

a.         0.82 g. / 13.1x11.0 mm

 

 

 

Enlargement of Em. 19a

 

b.                  0.87 g. / 14.1x11.0 mm

 

 

 

Obv.:      Tall beardless bust, diademed, with short hair facing right. Two aksharas in top right and top left corner.

(While the specimens in the author’s collection have a clear image of the lower part of the obverse, a similar variety sold by CNG in Auction 61, Lot 925, has a clear upper portion.)[16]

Rev.: Seated lion with open jaw facing left, tail curled upwards.

 

Ma / Rma   Ha / Pa

 

The first akshara is most probably a ‘Ma’ (‘rma’ has also been suggested while less likely), while the second has been read as ‘Ha’ or ‘Pa’.  Note the similarities in the facial features of the bust featured in this coin and that of Em. 17 above.

 

Four different seated lion varieties have been discovered by the author, some featuring unique sets of Brahmi aksharas.  The seated lion series will be addressed in detail in a subsequent article.

 

Group IV: Miscellaneous

 

20.

 

a.                   AE Unit

0.93 g/ 11.2x11.0

 

 

 

b.                  AE Unit

0.70 g. / 10.9x9.4 g.

 

 

 

Obv.:      Standing bull facing left

Rev.:      Undetermined; off flan

 

Two pieces were found in the hoard, both in fine condition with the reverse design almost entirely off flan.  The reason for including this coin in the Alxon group is that, like the above, they are struck on rectangular flans and the image is surrounded by a beaded border.  In the absence of better samples, it is difficult to speculate further on the nature of these pieces.

 

While the nandi bull is depicted along side standing Siva in Kidara and Kushano-Sasanian coins, a lone standing bull, features in the AE issues minted by Mihirakula (Gobl Hunnen Em. 151-159) in and around the capital city of Sakala.[17]

 

Not withstanding the fact that we lack any specimens with clear reverse designs, these coins can be tentatively attributed to Mihirakula’s reign.

 

 

21.       AE Unit

0.82 g. / 11.5x10.8 mm

 

 

 

 

Obv.:      Swastika with two curled ends

Rev.:      Swastika with one visible curled end

 

I would like to express my thanks to Dr. Munaf Billoo. The swastika, another early Indic symbol, is not commonly found in Hunnic coinage.   It has appeared as a countermark on Gobl Hunnen 295, a Peroz imitation of the Alxon “Genuine Hephthalites” series.  A derivation with a crescent at one end features on Gobl Hunnen Emission 108, a drachm of Toramana.

 

Given the fact that the reverse is partially off flan it is difficult to determine whether the swastika on the reverse is of a similar nature. 

 

22.       AE Unit

0.54 g. / 9.5x5.4 mm

 

 

 

Obv.:      Female deity standing facing right

Rev.:      Two Kobadian style tamghas within beaded border

 

The female deity on the obverse resembles Symboles 22 and 87, featured on Gobl Hunnen Emissions 91 and 149, more closely resembling the latter.  According to Gobl, this figure represents Lakshmi, standing on a lotus flower (the area below the legs in the above example is off the flan) and is derived from the “standing queen” image on the Asvamehda (horse sacrifice) dinars of Samudragupta.  Given the frequency of Ardoksho / Lakshmi portrayals on Kashmir Smast bronzes, it is likely that this too represents Lakshmi.  In both Emissions, the figure appears in front of the ruler’s bust.  Emission 91 is attributed to the later period of Khingila, while 149 is a later coin of Narendra, associated with the retreat from Gandhara into Bactria, and Gobl explains that it was possibly minted in Ghazni (post c. 570 AD).  This was the period of Alxon decline and tribal warfare, when according to Gobl, they suffered at the hands of the Nazek, the Western Turks, and what he describes as the “Genuine Hephthalites”.  Mitchiner places the Genuine Hephthalites as part of the Alxon group due to the Bactrian inscription “Alxon” on their Sasanian derivative drachms.

 

The symbol on the left portion of the reverse (and possibly the right symbol as well) appears to be Gobl’s tamgha 59.  The tamgha features on the right field of Gobl Em. 289, the Peroz imitation drachms of the Kobadian principality in Bactria.  Mitchiner describes these as derivatives of the Alxon drachms issued after the captivity of the Sasanian emperor Peroz by the Hephthalites in the latter half of the 5th century.[18]  The Kobadian drachms have been attributed to a TurkoHephthalite (Western Turk) kingdom of the late 6th century.  Since the entire flan is not visible, it is difficult to gauge the exact nature of the central tamgha. 

 

Therefore, it is possible to attribute this emission to the period of warfare between the Western Turks and the Alxon in the Ghazni area in the late 6th century, possibly to Narendra or later rulers.

 

Sources

 

Alram Alchon = Alram, Michael.  Alchon und Nezak Zur Geschichte der Iranischen Hunnen In Mittelasien.   La Persia E L'Asia Centrale - Da Alessandro Al X Secolo, Atti Dei Convegni Lincei 127.  Rome: Accademia Nazionale Dei Lincei, Roma, 1996.


Alram HCD = Alram, Michael. 'A Hoard of Copper Drachms From the Kapisa-Kabul Region,' Silk Road Art and Achaeology, Volume 6.  Kamakura: The Institute of Silk Road Studies, Kamakura, 2000.

Alram RHC = Alram, Michael.  'A Rare Hunnish Coin Type.'  Silk Road Art and Achaeology, Volume 8.  Kamakura: The Institute of Silk Road Studies, Kamakura, 2002.

 

Biswas = Biswas, Atreyi.  The Political History of the Hunas in India. New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal, 1973.

 

Callieri = Callieri, Pierfrancesco.  ‘Huns in Afghanistan and the North-West of the Indian Subcontinent: The Glyptic Evidence.’  Coins, Art, and Chronology: Essays on the Pre-Islamic History of the Indo-Iranian Borderlands. Wien: Osterreichischen Akademie Der Wissenschaften, Wien, 1999.

 

Choudhary = Choudhary, Radhakrishna.  ‘A Critical Study of the Coinage of the Hunas.’  Journal of the Numismatic Society of India: Volume XXV.  Varanasi: The Numismatic Society of India, 1964.

 

Gobl Hunnen = Gobl, Robert.  Dokumente Zur Geschichte Der Iranischen Hunnen In Baktrien Und Indien.  Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz, 1967.

 

Gobl IHM = Gobl, Robert.  'Iranish-Hunnische Munzen, 1. Nachtrag.'  Iranica Antiqua XVI, In Memorium Roman Ghirshman (2). Gent: 1981.

Gobl SOI = Gobl, Robert. 'Supplementa Orientalia I.' Litterae Numismaticae Vindobonenses 2. Wien: Osterreichischen Akademie Der Wissenschaften, Wien, 1983.

Gobl SOII = Gobl, Robert.  'Supplementa Orientalia II.'  Litterae Numismaticae Vindobonenses 3. Wien: Osterreichischen Akademie Der Wissenschaften, Wien, 1987.

 

Gobl SOIII = Gobl, Robert.  ‘Supplementa Orientala III.’  Quaderni Ticinesi Di Numismatica e Antichita Classiche 22.  1993.

 

Kuwayama = Kuwayama, Shohin.  ‘The Hephthalites in Tokharistan and Northwest India.’  Zinbun- November 24 (1989).  Kyoto: Institute for Research in Humanities, Kyoto University, 1989.

 

Litvinsky = Litvinsky, B.A., Ed.  History of the Civilizations of Central Asia, Volume III: The crossroads of civilizations: A.D. 250 to 750.  Paris: UNESCO Publishing, 1996.

 

Mitchiner ACW = Mitchiner, Michael. Oriental Coins, the Ancient and Classical World. London: Hawkins Publications, 1978.

Mitchiner ECCA = Mitchiner, Michael. The Early Coinage of Central Asia. London: Hawkins Publications, 1973.

 

Narain = Narain, A.K.  ‘Coins of Toramana and Mihirakula.’  Journal of the Numismatic Society of India: Volume XXIV.  Varanasi: The Numismatic Society of India, 1964.

 

Pieper = Pieper, Wilfried.  'A New Find of Small Copper Coins of Late 4th Century Gandhara.' ONS Newsletter No. 170. Surrey: Oriental Numismatic Society, 2002.

 

Qureshi = Qureshi, I.H., Ed.  A Short History of Pakistan: Book One- Pre-Muslim Period.  Karachi: University of Karachi, 1967.

 

Rtveladze = Rtveladze, E. The Ancient Coins of Central Asia. Tashkent, 1987.

 

Smirnova = Smirnova, O.I.  Svodnyi Katalog Sogdiiskikh Monet: Bronza. Moscow: Akademia Nauka CCCP, 1981.

 

Ziad AEI = Ziad, Waleed.  ‘AE Imitations of Indo-Greek Drachms from Swat.’ ONS Newsletter No. 181.  Surrey: Oriental Numismatic Society, 2004.

 

Online:

 

BMC Online = British Museum Collections online: Carved Wooden Plaque www.thebritishmuseum.ac.uk/compass/ixbin/goto?id=OBJ5991

 

CNG = Classical Numismatics Group site and Mail Bid Auction Catalogues.

www.cngcoins.com

 

Khan, Shaivite temple at Kashmir Smast =  Khan, Nasim.  ‘Shaivite Temple at Kashmir Smast: Study and Analysis.’  PANEL: The Temple in South Asia (Tuesday July 5 9.30 – 5.00)

www.ucl.ac.uk/southasianarchaeology/Temples.pdf

 

Mallon = The Coins and History of Asia

www.grifterrec.com/coins.coins.html

 

Silk Road = The Silk Road Foundation: The White Huns- The Hephthalites

www.silk-road.com/artl/heph.shtml

 

Soka Gakkai: Soka Gakkai Dictionary of Buddhism: Mihirakula

www.sgi-usa.net/buddhism/library/sgbd/lexicon

 

Zeno = Zeno: Oriental Coins database- Vladimir Belyaev, Moscow.

www.zeno.ru

 

Ziad ACCAP = Ancient and Classical Coins and Antiquities of Pakistan: the collection of Waleed Ziad. www.oocities.org/ziadnumis

 



[1] Alram HCD, 133.

[2] Gobl, 206.

[3] Gobl. 207.

[4] Mitchiner ACW, 232.

[5] Gobl, 219.

[6] Gobl, 175-176.

[7] Readings by Harry Falk, Dilip Rajgor, and Waleed Ziad.

[8] Gobl, Tafel 22-48.

[9] Rtveladze, 168.

[10] Göbl IHM, Em. 32A.

[11] Gobl, 214-215.

[12] Mitchiner ACW, 496, 599, 610.

[13] Gobl, 68-70

[14] Mitchiner ACW, 334-335.

[15] CNG, Auction 45, Lot 738.

[16] CNG, Auction 61, Lot 925.

[17] Narain, 6.

[18] Mitchiner ACW, 228.