Gee, Commodore Pellew
PELLEW: That it should come to this.  You of all people.
HORATIO:  It’s good of you to come.
PELLEW:  This is not a social call man!  Well, what do you have to say for yourself?

HORATIO:
Deeeeeeeear
Kindly captain Pellew
Ya gotta understand
It’s just the situation
Was getting out of hand
Our doctor was a junky
Our captain was insane
Golly, Moses, what was there to gain?

(Archie, Wellard, and Bush come out of nowhere to plead Horatio’s case)

HORATIO, ARCHIE, WELLARD AND BUSH:
Gee Commodore Pellew
We’re very upset
We never had the leadership
We were s’posed to get
We ain’t no delinquents
We’re misunderstood
We did the service losta good

HORATIO: Lotsa good!

ALL (HORATIO, ARCHIE, WELLARD AND BUSH):
Lotsa good, lotsa good,
What we did was good
Bringing order did us lotsa good

(Lt. Kennedy, report!)

ARCHIE:
Deeeeeeear
Kindly Captain Hammond
Our captain treats us rough
With all that rum and liquor
We never got enough
He didn’t want to have us
But orders made us had
Leapin’ lizards, please don’t think we’re bad

(Captains Hammond and Collins come in to give Pellew some support)

HAMMOND:
Now Commodore Pellew, I still think it’s wrong
This was trying to take over the whole time along

PELLEW:
But Captain Hammond, you’re such a square
You’re making this trial all unfair

HORATIO: So unfair!

ALL (INCLUDING PELLEW):
It’s unfair, it’s unfair, this is so unfair

PELLEW: This is making me lose all my hair!

WELLARD:
Myyyyyyyy
captain beats my bottom
And Randall beats on Styles
Our doctor pushes laud’num
And gets drunk all the while
My vision’s going blurry
As we’re all sailin’ west
Goodness gracious, that’s why we’re a mess

(Lt. Bush, report!)

BUSH:
Yes Commodore Pellew
We shouldn’t be here
We boys don’t need a cell
To damage all our careers
Tragedy’s plagued us, a terrible trick
Isn’t the hand of fate just sick!  (next column....)
HORATIO: It’s so sick!

ALL:
It is sick, it is sick
It is sick, sick, sick
Why doesn’t Sawyer’s psyche tick?

Deeeeeeeear
Kindly board of captains
They tell we’re berserk
“What kind of sailors are you?
You think mutiny works?”
It’s not we’re anti-navy
We’re only anti-jerk
Glory osky, why can’t our ship work?

HAMMOND:
Commodore Pellew, we’ve done it again
This boy needs a promotion, not his life in the pen
It’s only a question of misunderstood
You’re right, this kid is really good

HORATIO:  I am good!

ALL:
You’re so good, you’re so good
You are oh so good
The captains said that you are good!

ARCHIE:  The trouble is I’m dying
WELLARD:  The trouble is I’m dead
BUSH:  The trouble is I’m wounded
COLLINS:  Hey, when do we get fed?
PELLEW:  This trouble is I’m bias
HORATIO:  The trouble is I’m right
ALL:  Looky, will we ever win this fight?

ALL:
Gee, Commodore Pellew
We’re down on our knees
Don’t send us to the gallows now
We’re beggin’ ya please
Gee, Commodore Pellew, what are we to do?

Gee Commodore Pellew
Pell you!
Take me back to Manhattan...er...back to General Silliness
A parody of "Gee Officer Krupke" from West Side Story